Sub-Prime Memories are Short on Capitol Hill

November 19, 2008 by  
Filed under Economics, Loans and Borrowing

Barney Frank and his dysfunctional House Financial Services Committee held another hearing this week on the financial crisis.  This one featured appearances by Paulson, Bernanke, and the other usual suspects who are commanding U.S.S. Bailout.  In other words, many captains but still no navigator. 

I had an opportunity to listen to some of the hearing live on the radio while driving to an appointment outside the office.   (By the way, what is up with Chairman Frank and his diction?  If you didn’t know better, you would swear from the sound of his radio voice that he is either drunk, stoned, or recovering from an overdose of dental anesthetic.  He makes the late Harry Caray sound like a great orator.  It is painful to hear. )  

Early on in the hearing, Congresswoman Maxine Waters expressed her unhappiness that TARP (Troubled Assets Relief Program) funds were not being used to re-structure existing residential mortgages that were in default.  Apparently, Waters and her staff had formed their own little mortgage workout operation.   She stated that they were working with 26 different constituents who were behind on their mortgages.  She and her congressional operatives were quite frustrated because the various loan servicers they contacted were not very helpful on the phone.  Gosh, Maxine, welcome to our world of customer disservice.

So Maxine offered up her view that Sheila Bair, the FDIC Chair, had a great thing going at IndyMac Federal Bank (the failed bank taken over by the FDIC in July). Yes, Chairperson Bair had developed her own plan for re-structuring mortgage loans owned by IndyMac that were in default.  This is how she described the plan in an earlier press release and in testimony at the hearing:

Under the IndyMac program, eligible mortgages will be modified into sustainable mortgages permanently capped at the current Freddie Mac survey rate for conforming mortgages which is currently about 6.5%. Modifications are designed to achieve sustainable payments at a 38% debt-to-income (DTI) ratio of principal, interest, taxes and insurance. To reach this metric for affordable payments, modifications could adopt a combination of interest rate reductions, extended amortization, and principal forbearance.

Don’t you love the government speak in this description?  What is a “sustainable” mortgage?  A mortgage that goes on indefinitely without change?  If so, then the Bair-IndyMac plan will certainly create mortgages that are super-sustainable.

Let’s examine a couple of components of the plan advocated by Bair and now Waters.  First, Bair proposes creating affordable mortgage payments by “extended amortization.”  In plain language, this means taking a 30 year mortgage and extending it to 35 or 40 years.  The Bair plan also includes “principal forbearance.”  Once again applying the Tough Money Love plain language interpreter to this government-speak, she means an interest-only loan.

Do 40-year mortgages and interest-only loans ring a bell with you?   They do with me.  They ring alarm bells actually.   These are precisely the type of funny-money loans that the sub-prime lenders pushed into the market to inflate and sustain the real estate bubble.  Californians were particularly fond of these gadget mortgages.  (Can you guess where Maxine Waters is from?)  These are the loans that indeed last forever, with little or no equity being built by the borrower-home owner.  And these are the loans that folks like Bair and Waters now want to use to “rescue” those who cannot afford their existing mortages.  Pure genius.

Have Bair, Waters, and others on Capitol Hill forgotten where much of this mess started?   In fact, have they forgotten that IndyMac itself failed in part because of its own sub-prime loan portfolio?  I cannot see any long-term benefit of a government plan that systematically re-generates an entire portfolio of sub-prime loans for underfunded borrowers, guaranteed with taxpayer money.  Dear Capitol Hill:  The great “sub-prime loans for sub-prime borrowers” party has ended and the social experiment has failed.  Merely lowering the payment-to-income ratios is unlikely to significantly change the outcomes.  Even if the lowered payments prevent immediate foreclosures, the borrowers are not building equity with these aberrant loan terms and, in fact, may go further underwater.  Eventually, they may figure that out and walk away anyway.  It’s happening now. 

The cliche’ about history is that those who do not study it are bound to repeat it.  In the case of Sheila Bair, Maxine Waters, and others on Capitol Hill, memories have faded quickly and history is being forgotten.  Standby for the launching of U.S.S. Bailout II.


Feed Mr. ToughMoneyLove

FREE UPDATES: If you enjoyed this, please subscribe to receive the newest hard truth from Mr. ToughMoneyLove automatically by RSS feed (what is RSS?) or by spam-free Email.

Share
  • Banner

Comments

7 Responses to “Sub-Prime Memories are Short on Capitol Hill”
  1. Andrea says:

    What this does is create a feudal state, complete with indentured servants. Ok, not technically, but you know what I mean.

    I know it would cost a fortune, but I truly believe that at some point a massive mortgage adjustment process is going to have to happen. Not only for people who are in trouble but for everyone.

  2. Andrea – I like your indentured servant analogy. What the folks on Capitol Hill cannot seem to come to grips with is that there are thousands of people who became homeowners as the result of forcibly relaxed lending standards that simply are not prepared to be homeowners. They do not need to jury-rig loans to keep these people in the system.

  3. R Brown says:

    I think Capitol Hill needs to speak with companies that are making money and profit … The companies I am speaking about they do not sell stock ether to help there company grow… They need to do this fast …

  4. R Brown: Congress should at least require the auto companies to produce a detailed business plan that explains when and how they will turn a profit so that taxpayer loans can be repaid.

  5. janet carney says:

    I love too how these politicans (all Democrats) ignored the Bush driven- McCain/ Kyl endorsed plea two years ago to ADDRESS the upcoming Mortgage meltdown that was apparent – 2 members signed it – and yet the Babbling Maxine W. is on record saying Freddie and Fannie are fine – we have gone over the books are we are in good shape- HA! you can see tapes online- why isn;t this getting prime tiME COVERAGE ? bONUSES THAT rAINES AND ALL TOOK – PRICELESS – I MEAN PRICEY !!! LIES DECEPT AND CORRUPT SCONDRELS Can you tell i work in the Realty Industry – it is such a travesty — and it could have been avoided Even now they are making Modifications way too difficult – WHO HAS THE CURRENT VALUE OF THERE HOME WHEN VALUES HAVE GONE DOWN 30-40% in many neighborhoods ? Why don’t they broaden it across the board – offer lower rates – and keep people in there homes – they now by now how $$$costy Foreclosure is ——-this is the Worst Recessionary period ever and it ain’t getting better for awhile – Not with the current “powers” that be—-Sad- thanks for a good article- Raines retired – before ____ could hit the fan- now Pelosi-Waters and Mr. Barney need to do the same !!!!!!!

  6. janet carney says:

    Shoot – that was suppose to be 26 memebers of Congress !!! typo !

  7. janet carney says:

    I love too how these politicans (all Democrats) ignored the Bush driven- McCain/ Kyl endorsed plea two years ago to ADDRESS the upcoming Mortgage meltdown that was apparent – 26 members signed it – and yet the Babbling Maxine W. is on record saying Freddie and Fannie are fine – we have gone over the books are we are in good shape- HA! you can see tapes online- why isn;t this getting prime tiME COVERAGE ? bONUSES THAT rAINES AND ALL TOOK – PRICELESS – I MEAN PRICEY !!! LIES DECEPT AND CORRUPT SCONDRELS Can you tell i work in the Realty Industry – it is such a travesty — and it could have been avoided Even now they are making Modifications way too difficult – WHO HAS THE CURRENT VALUE OF THERE HOME WHEN VALUES HAVE GONE DOWN 30-40% in many neighborhoods ? Why don’t they broaden it across the board – offer lower rates – and keep people in there homes – they now by now how $$$costy Foreclosure is ——-this is the Worst Recessionary period ever and it ain’t getting better for awhile – Not with the current “powers” that be—-Sad- thanks for a good article- Raines retired – before ____ could hit the fan- now Pelosi-Waters and Mr. Barney need to do the same !!!!!!!

Speak Your Mind

Please leave a comment and tell us your version of the hard truth...

You must be logged in to post a comment.